|
You won the deal. A rigorous due diligence process
has been completed. But, the deal hasn't closed yet.
What can happen during this interim period that may
affect the success of the investment? A lot can
happen. It is unlikely that anyone ever regretted
employing a dose of skepticism. How can you
best protect your interests?
|
|
A Dose of Skepticism |
 |
When you're paying a multiple of earnings for a
company, you can't be too sure that revenues and
expenses are normalized and reflect a full year's
operations. Why would a seller invest in deferred
maintenance right before closing if it would reduce
proceeds from the sale? We have seen
overpayments in excess of $15MM to $20MM, simply
due to the specific day of the month or year that a
deal closed. Once the discrepancies were discovered
in these cases, the buyers' only remedy was litigation.
Needless to say, they did not end up whole.
To protect yourself from timing discrepancies, and to
ensure a remedy for your Reps & Warranties, we
suggest structuring a seller's note. The note should
remain in place until post-acquisition diligence is
completed and all Reps & Warranties fulfilled. Barring
the ability to negotiate a seller's note, your only
alternative is to conduct as much diligence as
possible, right up to the closing bell. A month, week
or even a day can make a multi-million dollar
difference.
Whether conducted immediately prior to or post
closing, due diligence should cover:
- Accounting Practices: search for patterns
of accounting that may be considered acceptable, but
are aggressive or marginal in nature.
- Sales: examine sales cutoff, channel
stuffing,
evaluate sales returns for improper shipping at or
near transaction close, analyze sales returns and
discounts as a percentage of sales and compare to
historical periods, identify bill and hold transactions,
corroborate sales mix percentages, stratify sales
terms and match to cash flow
projections/forecasting.
- Cost of Sales: test gross margins at
product
category level, identify SKU level loss leaders, identify
variable vs. fixed costs contributors to COS.
- SG&A: test validity of business vs. non
business
related expenses, test number of paid people to
actual headcount, identify non recurring items.
- Reps & Warranties: determine if all items
are as
disclosed, if undisclosed items are an issue and/or
negatively impact working capital and/or possible
contingent liabilities.
- Contracts: evaluate contingent
liabilities, "evergreen" provisions, "kickbacks."
- Cash: examine aged reconciling items,
inquire
about remaining terms of restricted cash, evaluate
cash management and banking relationships.
- Accounts Receivable: examine new
customer
credits, match customer write-offs with bad debt
expense, evaluate new aged debtors for improper
sales.
- Inventory: evaluate in-transit receipts for
validity,
review sales cutoff for "bill and hold" transactions,
investigate obsolescence amounts, test inventory
pricing consistency, evaluate cycle count procedures,
consider possible purchase commitments, examine
ABL lending terms and reconcile to recent compliance
certificate.
- PP&E: evaluate asset control procedures
(e.g.,
tagged office equipment), evaluate UCC filings,
compare capitalization amounts with stated policy and
or for reasonableness.
- Other Assets: verify security deposits and
validity
of prepaid expenses, verify expiration of NOLs,
evaluate intangibles with new accounting standards,
look for and challenge miscellaneous debits.
- Accounts Payable: examine payment
terms and
working capital requirements, update approved
vendor listing.
- Accrued Expenses: compare accruals
between
periods, evaluate deferred revenue, inquire about
contingent liabilities, verify accruals for quarterly taxes
(e.g., sales and property taxes).
- Debt: examine credit agreements for debt
covenant compliance and any cross default
provisions, cure remedies & requirements, calculate
debt service requirements.
- Leases: evaluate current lease
obligations (i.e.,
bargain purchase option), assess the discounted
cash flow of the lease(s).
A senior, experienced professional conducting this
final-hour or post-closing diligence brings a healthy
dose of skepticism to the process. As a result, the
buyer can be more assured that their best interests
are protected.

|
|
About Brandlin & Associates |
 |
Brandlin & Associates is an exclusive provider of
investigative accounting, financial consulting and
strategic consulting services. We pride ourselves on
offering superior technical expertise, years of
practical experience and unparalleled service to
decipher financial and operational performance
metrics. As a result, our clients are able to make
informed decisions in a timely manner.
|